Happy Valley

Craftgate vs Recurly

Craftgate and Recurly are both payments & billing tools. Craftgate is aimed at small businesses and enterprise, while Recurly is aimed at enterprise.

Craftgate

One-stop payment orchestration platform

Recurly

Subscription management for growing brands

PricingPaidPaid · $249
Starting priceNot published$249/mo
Free planNoNo
Free trial—90 days
Built forSmall businesses, Enterprise, DevelopersEnterprise
Platformswebweb
CountryTRUS · 2009
Rating——

Choose Craftgate if

Merchants, marketplaces and platforms that work with several banks and payment providers.

  • Independent payment orchestration
  • Reduces dependency on one provider
  • Better authorization rates via routing

Look elsewhere if: Small stores using one gateway.

Choose Recurly if

Consumer and media subscription businesses.

  • Strong failed payment recovery
  • Good for consumer subscriptions
  • Gateway flexibility

Look elsewhere if: Early SaaS (Stripe Billing).

Craftgate vs Recurly pricing

Craftgate

  • CustomCustomCommission agreed per merchant; no public rates

Recurly

  • Starter$249/mo+0.9% of billing volume; first $40K/mo included
  • All-AccessCustom<1% of billing volume; $1M volume minimum
  • All-Access for ShopifyCustomRecurly integrated into Shopify

Craftgate · Key features

  • Single integration to virtual POS, payment institutions and alternative methods
  • Smart and dynamic payment routing
  • Retry of failed payments through an alternative provider
  • Autopilot continuity during POS downtime
  • Payment gateway, card storage, one-click and recurring payments
  • Link and QR payments and fraud management

Cons

  • Value grows with multiple POS agreements
  • Pricing quote-based

Recurly · Key features

  • Subscription plans and promotions
  • Revenue recovery and smart retries
  • Multi-gateway support
  • Subscription analytics
  • Revenue recognition
  • Gift and trial management

Cons

  • Revenue-based fees
  • Less popular with SaaS startups
  • Implementation effort

Craftgate vs Recurly: FAQ

Do Craftgate and Recurly have a free plan?

Craftgate has no free plan. Recurly has no free plan, a 90-day free trial.

Which is better for small businesses, Craftgate or Recurly?

Craftgate lists small businesses as a core audience, while Recurly is aimed more at enterprise.

Not sure yet?

Craftgate vs Recurly (2026): Pricing and Features