Fourthwall vs Memberful
Fourthwall and Memberful are both creator monetization tools. Fourthwall is aimed at creators and E-commerce, while Memberful is aimed at creators and small businesses. Fourthwall costs less, from $15/mo versus $49/mo for Memberful. Only Fourthwall has a free plan.
Creator storefront for merch, memberships and digital products
Membership software for your own site
| Pricing | Freemium · $15 | Paid · $49 |
| Starting price | $15/mo | $49/mo |
| Free plan | Yes | No |
| Free trial | — | — |
| Built for | Creators, E-commerce | Creators, Small businesses |
| Platforms | web | web |
| Country | US · 2019 | US · 2013 |
| Rating | — | — |
Choose Fourthwall if
Video creators and streamers who want merch, memberships and digital products in one branded shop without managing inventory.
- No inventory or upfront cost to launch merch
- Merch, memberships and digital products in one branded shop
- Fourthwall handles fulfillment and support for catalog orders
Look elsewhere if: Brands that need a fully custom store or sellers of digital products only (Shopify, Gumroad).
Choose Memberful if
Creators with their own site.
- Keep your own site
- WordPress integration
- Private podcasts
Look elsewhere if: Creators without sites (Patreon).
Fourthwall vs Memberful pricing
Fourthwall
- Free$05% fee on digital products and memberships; 2 team members
- Pro$15/moSave $48 paying yearly; no digital fee, custom domain
Memberful
- Standard$49/moPlus 4.9% transaction fee; unlimited members
- EnterpriseCustomCustom volume pricing
Fourthwall · Key features
- Print-on-demand catalog of 200+ products with costs deducted per sale
- Own-product sourcing, samples and production through vetted partners
- Paid memberships with members-only videos and a branded mobile app
- Digital downloads up to 5 GB on Free and 100 GB on Pro
- YouTube, TikTok, Instagram and Twitch selling and on-stream alerts
- Customizable shop themes with promo codes and giveaways
Cons
- 5% fee on memberships even on Pro
- Print-on-demand margins are thin on low-priced items
- Less design freedom than a full Shopify store
Memberful · Key features
- Memberships on your site
- Gated content
- Private podcasts
- Discord roles
- Stripe billing
- Group subscriptions
Cons
- Fees
- Requires your site
- Limited community features
Fourthwall vs Memberful: FAQ
Which is cheaper, Fourthwall or Memberful?
Fourthwall starts at $15/mo and Memberful at $49/mo. Both prices are checked on the vendors' own pricing pages.
Do Fourthwall and Memberful have a free plan?
Fourthwall has a free plan. Memberful has no free plan.
Which is better for small businesses, Fourthwall or Memberful?
Memberful lists small businesses as a core audience, while Fourthwall is aimed more at creators and E-commerce.