Cometly vs Madgicx
Cometly and Madgicx are both ad management & attribution tools aimed at E-commerce and agencies.
Ad attribution with server-side conversion sync for paid media teams
AI optimization for Meta ads
| Pricing | Paid | Paid |
| Starting price | Not published | Not published |
| Free plan | No | No |
| Free trial | — | 7 days |
| Built for | E-commerce, Agencies, Small businesses | E-commerce, Agencies |
| Platforms | web | web |
| Country | US · 2021 | IL · 2018 |
| Rating | — | — |
Choose Cometly if
Performance marketers and agencies spending heavily on Meta and Google who need revenue-level attribution and server-side conversion sync.
- Feeds cleaner conversion data back to ad platform algorithms
- Connects ad spend to CRM pipeline, not just ecommerce checkouts
- Unlimited ad platform connections on both plans
Look elsewhere if: Shopify-first brands or small advertisers wanting self-serve, low-cost analytics (Triple Whale, Northbeam or Hyros may fit better).
Choose Madgicx if
E-commerce brands heavy on Meta ads.
- Strong Meta creative insights
- Automation saves time
- Free trial to start
Look elsewhere if: Search-first advertisers.
Cometly vs Madgicx pricing
Cometly
- CoreCustom quotePriced by monthly pageviews; attribution, CAPI sync, AI Ads Manager
- EnterpriseCustom quoteAdds warehouse sync, API, MCP and a dedicated team
Madgicx
- Pro Complete (with AI)CustomPrice shown in app; depends on monthly ad spend
- Tracking Pro add-on$49/moPer connected account
Cometly · Key features
- First-party pixel plus server-side tracking that survives browser restrictions
- Multi-touch attribution models comparing first, last and linear credit
- Conversion API sync back to Meta, Google, TikTok, LinkedIn and Reddit
- Account and customer journey views from first click to closed revenue
- AI Ads Manager for analyzing and adjusting campaigns from one screen
- Custom dashboards joining ad spend with CRM and Stripe revenue
Cons
- No free trial and no public pricing
- Small team and company, so roadmap and support depend on few people
- Setup requires CRM, pixel and ad account work before data is useful
Madgicx · Key features
- Creative insights and analytics
- Audience launcher
- Automation tactics and rules
- AI ad copy and creatives
- Cross-channel reporting
- One-click reports
Cons
- Meta-focused
- Automation needs oversight
- Learning curve
Cometly vs Madgicx: FAQ
Do Cometly and Madgicx have a free plan?
Cometly has no free plan. Madgicx has no free plan, a 7-day free trial.
Which is better for small businesses, Cometly or Madgicx?
Cometly lists small businesses as a core audience, while Madgicx is aimed more at E-commerce and agencies.